Thursday, May 14, 2009

Sharky's Pick-N-Click Rating


O.K. I was maybe a little hard on the Zimmerman Agency’s “Pick-N-Click” Agency model. Like the Automat, you see and use what you want in terms of a campaign and it’s that simple.

I like to assume the creatives at Zimmerman/Pick-N-Click get paid a decent wage. Heck maybe even a living wage. Some one has to create the variety needed to keep the car dealer clients happy. At least the creatives have a chance to say what they expect to be paid at the interview when they first start out at Zimmerman, right?

But I am going to stick with my 3 Golem Rating for
Zimmerman's Pick-N-Click




© Copyright 2009 Guy Arceneaux All rights reserved

crowdSPRING: WHOPPING 4 GOLEMS!!




crowdSPRING is different.
Very different.

Well, when I posted a virtual agencies discussion online at one of my LinkedIn groups I kept seeing references to crowdSPRING pop up.

I must be very out of the loop, because I had never heard of crowdSPRING. But according to their website they have only been up and running for about a year.

They were also apologizing for the bad behavior of their servers, and their own shortsightedness (is that really a word?). They obviously are experiencing growing pains.

The crowdSPRING Model— “We’re the marketplace for creative services.”

A) Post a creative brief, (a good thing)

B) Then a budget amount, (again, a good thing ostensibly)

C) Then a completion date is posted
This feels familiar to anyone with an agency background. But the budget amounts are astoundingly low. As a “CREATIVE” participating in a project, you submit your numerous iterations to the site and anyone can see them! There are tons of them. Some are really nice some are awful and still your chance of getting picked is on average 1 out of 68, a whopping 68 responses for every project submitted!

Here is what they promise to the “CLIENTS” who they call “BUYERS”:

Name your price
Launch your project on your budget, not someone else's.

So if you just want to pay $200 for a logo (corporate identity) you can do that, you are the buyer. That seems very low to me.

Name your deadline

See entries within hours and be done in just days.

Wow! I, as a client love the idea of a designer, nay, many designers jumping when I say jump. Not only when I say jump but how high! The ultimate in modern day net slavery. Think desktop publishing sweatshops.
Ridiculous choice

The average project gets a whopping 68 entries.

This is a great selling point for me as a designer, work my caffeine addled brain into a frenzy to complete with 68 or more other professionals for a measly sum. As Oliver Twist might say, "More, sir"

Money back guarantee

25 entries or your money back.

This kills me, no agency ever promises that, they hard sell a client until they submit. Just kidding, but you do sell the variations you present, you stand behind them. To say that you have presented something unworthy of their startegic need is a self-defeating stance.

15,000+ creatives

Your virtual creative team in over 140 countries.

This is just astounding, I really don’t have anything to say about it except, bye, bye, job security.

We’re here to help

Seven days a week. (although we occasionally sleep).

So are your servers lately, it seems.

Exceptional quality

Never sacrifice quality for budget or deadline.

Well that sign on my wall which says pick two: quality, budget or deadline.
It is evidently very old school and does not apply in this model.

Free contract

So you know you have full ownership of your final design.

This flies in the face of everything the Graphic Artist Guild Handbook says about ownership of design.

Here is what they promise to the talent who they call “CREATIVES”:

It's easy find the projects you like, submit your ideas and get paid when yours is the best

It’s true the variety of projects were interesting and at least they had a coherent brief to accompany them. But I feel time spent on a job should be compensated.

Payment escrow

We hold the buyer's money— so no abandoned projects.

I usually ask for a third of the payment up front.

IP protection

No stealing ideas. No concept copying. No way.

So how does that happen when everyone can see the submissions?

No bidding

Stop trying to be the lowest bidder— start designing.

At $200 a pop I don’t think I could start designing for very long before I would have to stop.

You're in charge

Work on the projects that you want, when you want.

I do that anyway, don’t you?

Top projects

Some of the biggest brands in the world post projects.

Hmmmm. I am so swayed by this one. I did a $200 brand identity for Timberland!

How does that sound? It makes me sound like a fool for giving my creative capital away.

Awesome community

22,000+ creatives all working together, learning and growing.

This is just so compelling, if I get involved with anymore online communities I will just go mad! Mad I tell you!!

Sharpen your skills

Build your portfolio, win clients and perfect your craft.

This is one good selling point, but I think that part of your professionalism dies when you do work for spec.

We're here to help

Seven days a week (although we occasionally sleep).

Again, I think they were asleep when they worked up this business model.



© Copyright 2009 Guy Arceneaux All rights reserved

Wednesday, May 6, 2009

Virtual Ad Agencies Next for Golem Culture?

The Prague Golem figure—symbol for soul-less online agencies. Zimmerman gets a three-golem rating in my book. SOUL-less X 3.


Zimmerman President Pat Patregnani and Michael Gelfano, VP of retail technologies, demonstrate how Pick-N-Click works.

The virtual agency! It was a term that was floated often when I worked at Euro RSCG 4D, but it mainly described our partnering with multiple talent sources and sister agencies (is this term sexist?). The idea of an actual agency with no bricks and mortar office space but run online solely is an interesting idea.
Font size
There is one agency, Zimmerman and Partners Advertising, that I found. They have set up a virtual extension of themselves aimed at serving a big part of their clientele and vertical market—car dealers. They call it Pick-N-Click, and it apparently enables auto dealers to create whatever they need online.

"It took 66 software code writers, $3 million up front and input from a number of talented people to perfect the virtual agency," said Michael Gelfano, Zimmerman's VP of retail technologies.

Pick-N-Click enables a business owner or manager to create ads for print, radio and TV from pull-down menus with 40,000 selections. Licensing costs to use Pick-N-Click range from $799 to $1,999 a month, depending on how many medias a company uses.

"We did $2 billion in billings last year, with about 860 employees and with a pragmatic focus on performance for our clients, so Pick-N-Click fits right in with our strategy," said Michael Goldberg, chief marketing officer for the Fort Lauderdale-based agency.

The agency specializes in automotive accounts, so its officials said they chose to introduce the virtual agency to that niche first.


The website seems to cover it all in the navigation buttons, Strategy, Creative and Inventory. Wow, what more could you want? Passion? Intelligence? Brilliance?

While I think this is all very creative and forward thinking, I have always wondered why auto ads are so god-awful, and now I know why. They really aren't about high concept, breakthrough creative at least on the dealer level.

The reason I got into advertising was to participate in that high concept, breakneck pace, intellectually stimulating environment. Although I did work on the Saab Auto account for a while (and it was a pleasant experience). I regret now that I gave most of my creative energies to sell freaking credit cards for all those years. It all seems so, unfulilling, so golem like, soul-less and lucrative.

But I digress my friends—so this is just one virtual business model, Zimmerman is a large agency or rather part of the large conglomerate Omnicom. The upfront costs of this were, I am sure, a result of detailed study by many marketing wonks (i.e. account types). The creatives were most likely only brought in to execute the cosmetics, and I am sure they never were consulted on the actual planning of the user interface. Excuse me, am I sounding a bit arch?

The dream of setting up templates into which content can be placed has been trotted out repeatedly. In fact by every single general manager I have had the pleasure to work with over the years. The idea too, that you can "save" unused creative concepts has been around from the days when I kept a flat file full of them—beautifully realized tissue comps to be saved for the next time.

Yeah right! How many times did the perfect storm of product, strategy and client taste ever present itself again.

Anyway, I will be doing more investigation into this virtual agency concept because I think you can do it with out it seeming like a Golem-like creation from the soul-less inanimate material from which all Golem are wrought. As I do this investigation I will be assigning online agencies a Golem rating.

Zimmerman gets Sharky's 3 Golem rating,

4 Golems is the worst!

Stay tuned, leave a comment! G.


© Copyright 2009 Guy Arceneaux All rights reserved

Sunday, May 3, 2009

Layoffs in the Ad World Force Many Back to School


I won't name names and certainly won't name agencies, but there have been many layoffs in the past year. The number of my colleagues out of work right now is rather alarming. These people are what I would have considered indispensable. Not only are many designers and writers once again freelancing, but the people that they reported to are also looking or have been forced to accept positions at a different level.

Going back to school is a step many have chosen to upgrade their skills. Print designers are confronting Dreamweaver, when InDesign was their forte in the past. Many are not ready for the rude awakening of the need to understand the basics of HTML. Many just never thought they would be put in a position to learn coding of any sort.

The Web is Your Tutor
Before you go out and spend mucho dinero on books, check out some of the resources available for free online. Try this one for a basic HTML tutorial:
This site appears to be free and also also offers a comprehensive set of tutorials to bring the avid learner
up to speed on HTML, CSS, XML and my favorite Javascript.

This is just one of many sites available, I am not accepting payment from this site, I just found them with a simple Google search using the phrase, "Learning basic HTML".

Dreamweaver is HTML and WYSIWYG Combined
When I first taught myself Dreamweaver (I am still learning), I had already taught myself HTML (I am still learning). The ability to view the visual layout and the HTML coding simultaneously was a real productivity booster.

Using some online tutorials and a Quick Start book, I was able to get enough skills to work on some projects at the agency where I worked. I actually value books because of their accessibility. Its all a matter of your personal learning style.

Set a Personal Project as a Goal
  • It is important to have a real project in mind. When you are learning a web-based skill set choose a personal project that you can manage, with all that entails. When I taught myself HTML, it was for a nonprofit client's project to be presented at a meeting, this put pressure on me at the time, but that's how I work best. No one had ever suggested a web site to any of our clients, and it caused a great deal of discussion. (1996)
  • Set aside a special time to dive into the new area you are trying to learn. Even an hour spent three times a week is good enough, I think of this approach as planting redwood seedlings.
  • Visit online forums and professional gatherings. You will be surprised at how much you can pick up from casual contact with others in the new area you are learning.
  • Use your new skills as often as possible. Try to keep up with new developments in techniques that last suggestion might prove to be a career-long effort. Don't be daunted by what I call the learning spiral.
  • Keep learning. Many things you learn today, will one day be outmoded. Sigh!


© Copyright 2009 Guy Arceneaux All rights reserved


Thursday, April 23, 2009

Too much print..not enough web?


Last night in downtown Baltimore at an artist's club/bar called The Windup Space I particpated as a presenter, along with Alissa Jones of Six Red Marbles, in a roundtable discussion hosted by the Baltimore Aquent office. It was the first in a new monthly series they have started, last night being the innaugural trial run. The idea is to broach emerging topics of interest to the design community.

The theme was meant to bring to light in a discussion what steps other designers have made in making the transition from print design to web as demand has grown. The following are the slides from my presentation. I looked at it from the designers viewpoint and the future of the industry as a whole. Forgive the clunky long slide by slide posting, but the upload of a .mov file was not working at 6:30 this morning!

I chose not to detail what I have done to make the transition. I have done what many in the field have done, run as fast as I could up a steep learning curve since graphic design was inexorably bound to the use of the computer. Alissa took an entirely different, yet fascinating look at graphic design evolution through the lens of the historical development of the web.

Please leave your comments! I'd like to hear from you.

Comment Callout: Peter Kaizer, Director of Catholic Relief Services Web Unit left a great comment that had a link to a downloadable PDF. Peter said designers might be well informed by the following—"Jeffrey Zeldman got his start as a well known author with his first book, Taking Your Talent to the Web ."

This PDF definitely looks like a worthy addition to the substance of this discussion. Thanks, Peter! Your balanced and informed comments are much appreciated.



































© Copyright 2009 Guy Arceneaux All rights reserved

Sunday, March 22, 2009

My mentor, Marc Arceneaux

As a young artist still in high school, I had the good fortune to have an older brother, six years my senior. He was a creative person naturally, and words were often paired with his witty drawings.

When I was ready to decide what I wanted to study I followed in his footsteps and traveled to San Francisco to study at The San Francisco Art Institute. San Francisco in 1971 was still a wild and wooly place but much of the aura of the Summer of Love had degenerated into a much funkier harder edged scene.

But it was still a very good place to be, as a designer and as a curious art student. My brother was always encouraging during my art school years and introduced me to many of the founding schools of thought that built modern day design. He was an enthusiast of Bauhaus design, and always shared books he had found.

When he landed a contract to author two books on design history; Streamline: The Art and Design of the Forties and Atomic Age: The Art and Design of the Fifties, I was fortunate to work alongside him. We did fascinating research into these design eras. It was also my first exposure to publishing and having my art published. That foundation in Streamline and Atomic design has stayed with me always. Thanks, Marc.

10 Things I Learned From My Brother

1) Preliminary sketches are important.

2) Good design is inherent in a beautiful life plan.

3) Typography is important and historically grounded
in our psyche.

4) Raymond Lowie is a god.

5) Things will work out.

6) Treat everyone with respect, everyone is
an artist in their own way.

7) Borrowing from art history to create something new
is perfectly acceptable.

8) Use excellent art supplies and care for them.

9) Never let anyone borrow your personal Rapidograph.

10) Learn as much as you can about computer design.
(His advice in 1976)

© Copyright 2009 Guy Arceneaux All rights reserved

Neo-Nouveau Artist in California


The logo for Sylvandale Gardens, in California, takes its distinctive look from hand-lettered typography. It shows the elegant curvilinear balance of a well-trained eye coordinated with controlled pen strokes. It is simply superior to an artist using Illustrator or Photoshop.

Sharky's Artist Profile, My Brother:

Marc Jahn Arceneaux

Marc Jahn Arceneaux is a native of New Orleans and evacuated before Huricane Katrina. He took with him only a few of his favorite artworks. Today he shares his story with us and a few of the saved pieces. His career as an artist and author spans over 40 years and a variety of artistic endeavors. He has maintained successful studios in New York, San Francisco, Los Angeles, and New Orleans. He is a graduate of the Maryland Institute College of Art. Marc Arceneaux published 14 books, including his art history books "Streamline Art & Design of the Forties" and "Atomic Age Art & Design of the Fifties." The New York Art Directors Club awarded Marc The Gold Award in 1975 for his contributions to National Lampoon's million seller book release, "Kaleidoscope: The 1964 Yearbook Parody" on which the movie Animal House was based. He was also part of the 60s and 70s San Francisco golden era of album cover design, creating hand lettered logos for Canned Heat, Bobby Gentry, Danny O'Keefe, and Herbie Hancock, among others. More recently, Marc's 1997 Budweiser Mardi Gras poster became an instant classic. In 2000, he completed two large murals for the lobby of the Royal St. Charles Hotel.




© Copyright 2009 Guy Arceneaux All rights reserved